Old-Fashioned Apple Butter


Just plain, old-fashioned apple butter! Slow-cooked apples & spices bring back memories of eating fat hunks of warm bread, slathered in melted butter with a scoop of apple butter. Wonderful! 16oz.- $6.25



Click to Order:
$6.25 a jar
     
Pumpkin Butter

It's delicious on a piece of buttery toast, or warmed & spooned over ice cream. It's a must at any holiday table! A lovely blend of pumpkin, citrus & spices. $5.25 - 8 oz jar.

 


Click to Order:
$5.25 a jar
     
Indiana Watermelon Jam!

Smells & tastes just like a watermelon! A beautiful red pink juicy jam to enjoy on your morning toast.Crack the lid on this jam on a cold winter morning. Try not to wish you could be sweaty & sunburned. A tasty touch of Indiana summer captured in a little glass jam jar. Yummy! $5.25
SOLD OUT!
     
NEW!
New & Improved Naturally Sweetened Jams- No Sugar-Added

New flavors & new naturally sweetened jams! We now use a combination of Oligofructose & erithytol to sweeten our no-sugar added jams.
These are 100% natural sweeteners derived from plant fibers & have a glycemic index of zero. Tastes absolutely wonderful! No bitter, chemical after taste that is familiar with artificial sweeteners 8 oz Jar
Flavors
Click to Order:
$5.95 a jar
     

Cheery Cherry Apricot Jam


Apricot lovers will love this great tangy combination of apricots and tart cherries. A beautiful warm red jam that will brighten your morning toast!

$5.25 8 oz. Jar


Click to Order:
$5.25 a jar
     

Blackberry Jam

Simple blackberry jam. Highly suggested, many requested- so, now you have a simple, luscious blackberry jam!

$5.25 8 oz. Jar


Click to Order:
$5.25 a jar
   

Strawberry Jam

For those of you who just want a plain strawberry jam- we give you a great little jam made with just strawberries...t
here’s nothing plain about a strawberry!

$5.25 8 oz. Jar


Click to Order:
$5.25 a jar
   
Strawberry Margarita Jam

Put on your favorite sombrero, drop some bread in the toaster & get ready for some sassy slathering! We've put the great flavors of one of our favorite poolside libations in a jar! Strawberries, zesty lime, a little orange & a dash of tequila! Muy bueno!
$5.25- 8oz. jar



Click to Order:
$5.25 a jar
     
Pina Colada Paradise Jam

A tropical treat of pineapple, coconut & rum!
Great on your morning toast or as a snack
with cream cheese with crackers.
$5.25- 8oz. jar


Click to Order:
$5.25 a jar
     
Summer Splash

We captured the summer's bounty in a jar.
Peach, apricot and a splash of red raspberries.
$5.25 - 8 oz jar

Click to order
$5.25 per jar
     

I Love You Jam

Dark chocolate & red raspberries:
great on any bread, bagels or toast...
Even better on ice cream! Yum!
$5.25 - 8 oz jar

 

Click to Order:
$5.25 a jar

     
Carrot Cake Jam

Carrots, pears, spices…all that is missing is the cream cheese icing! A delicious treat!
$5.25 - 8 oz jar

 

Click to Order:
$5.25 a jar

     
Spiced Peach Jam
Fresh peach pie every time you open the jar!
Peaches mixed with a tasty combination of
spices make this jam one of our customer’s
favorites! Have a little peach pie with
breakfast every day!
$5.25 - 8 oz jar

Click to order
$5.25 per jar
     
Cherries & Hooch Jam
Big, bright red, tart cherries paired with
sultry almond liquor. A great flavor
combination to dollop on buttery toast or
a crispy, buttery English muffin. Warm some
up and use as a side for baked ham. For
dessert, warm more up and
spoon on creamy vanilla ice cream.
$5.25 - 8 oz jar

Click to order
$5.25 per jar
     
Pepper Patch Jam
Jalapenos stirred in with sweet red & yellow
bell peppers! It’s a great combination that is
sweet enough for your morning toast.
A lovely grilling glaze for chicken, pork and
fish. Just slather it on the meat a couple
of minutes before taking it off the heat.
Put some in a side dish for dipping!!
$ 5.25 - 8 oz jar
 

Click to order
$5.25 per jar
     
Meme’s Spring Blush Jam
This is our grandmother’s recipe. She wasn’t
just any grandmother, she was our Meme.

Spring Blush Jam is made of this season
fresh rhubarb crop, strawberries and
pineapple. Enjoy this lovely taste of
spring and nostalgia on your morning toast,
muffins or bagels. 8 oz jar


Click to order
$4.95 per jar
     
Very, Merry Bunch O’ Berries

Yes, indeed! A big bunch of berries all crammed
into this little jar! Raspberries, blueberries, blackberries and cranberries. Voted “Best Jam
of the Year” by the family! Great for gift giving!
$5.25 - 8 oz jar

Click to order
$5.25 per jar
     

Cranberry-Orange Sauce

Tart cranberries matched up with orange,
pineapple, raisins & spices. A perfect side for
turkey, great on that left-over turkey sandwich,
spoon some on your roast pork or
roast chicken! $5.25 - 8 oz jar

Click to order
$5.25 per jar
     
GRANDAD'S ORCHARD GINGERY CITRUS PEAR MARMALADE

Grandad wanted us to point out that he doesn't have any oranges in his orchard...just a lot of pears!
So, we took all his pears and cooked
up a batch of delicious, rich pear marmalade with hints of ginger and citrus.
$5.25 - 8 oz jar

Click to Order
$5.25 per jar
     


GRANNIE'S GARDEN SWEET DILL PICKLES


An old family recipe that brings back memories! Enjoy the unique flavor of a "sweet dill" pickle!
$5.95 - 16 oz jar


Click to Order
$5.95 per jar
     

Red Pepper & Apricot Chutney

A wonderful combination of red pepper and apricots mixed with raisins, onion, garlic and spices. Serve warm with roast chicken or pork. Great on top of baked fish. Spread it on sandwiches! Love it on warm brie and crackers!
$5.50 - 8 oz jar

Click to Order
$5.50 per jar
     

NEW! Pineapple Chutney

This is really, really good! On a lot if things! Pineapple, green peppers, almonds & golden raisins simmered in garlic and ginger. Great on roast chicken & roast pork. Love it on salmon! Mix it with shredded cabbage, a little mayo & sour cream and you’ve got a great side dish! Not that hungry? Top it on some cheese and crackers!

$5.50 - 8 oz jar

Click to Order
$5.50 per jar
     

Zesty Sweet Mustard

A new favorite for dipping pretzels!
Great on sandwiches, perfect on roast beef or pork!
We’ll be serving it this summer with our all-beef hot dogs! Yum!!
$5.25 - 8 oz jar

Click to Order
$5.25 per jar
     

Tangy Tomato Jam

We had a few requests, so we put Mom to the test!
It’s so good! This is a very versatile preserve; spread it on your morning toast, or serve it with chicken, pork or beef. It’s great on sandwiches or cheese & crackers. Delicious.
$5.25 - 8 oz jar

Click to Order
$5.25 per jar
     
Indiana Sweet Onion Relish

Another great find for the holiday table:
Indiana Sweet Onions, red peeper & spices.
Warm and serve with beef or pork. Great on sandwiches! Pour on top of cream cheese,
serve with crackers & bread!
$ 5.25 - 8 oz jar


Click to Order
$5.25 per jar
     
CORN RELISH
An old-fashioned favorite; sweet corn, cabbage, peppers in a sweet & tangy vinaigrette.
Perfect side dish! Serve it on salad, great with
tortilla chips, sour cream & salsa! 16 oz jar


Click to Order:
$5.95 per jar
     
Senora Rita Z’s Jalapeno-Cucumber Relish

It’s an old secret family recipe! Senora Rita Z’s will tantalize your taste buds with the coolness cucumbers wrapped with heat of the jalapeno! Great on burgers, hot dogs & brats!Sandwiches! Top some cream cheese, serve it with crackers! Ole! $5.25


Click to Order:
$5.25 per jar
     
Hot Carrots!

Crispy, tangy carrot sticks in a jar! Great for snackin', garnishes for cocktails, sandwiches, wraps- nice little extra! Garlic & red pepper give the carrots the zip, zing that hot carrot thang! Sign up! $5.50


Click to Order:
$5.50 per jar
     
HOT & SOUR DILLY BEANS!
Long & crisp green beans, a little sour with just a little heat. Perfect for garnishing drinks! Sunday morning Bloody Mary’s! Great on hot dogs, brats & burgers! Look for the dilly Beans in our Happy Hour Basket!
12 oz Jar
SOLD OUT!
     
HOT& SOUR DILLY BEAN BITS!
Just the bits! Crisp green beans, a little sour with just a little heat. Great on top of salads, a cool side dish or top some cheese & crackers! 16oz. jar
SOLD OUT!
     
SWEET ZUCCHINI RELISH
A great combination of zucchini, onion, peppers and spices. Serve it up on hamburgers, hot dogs, sandwiches, cheese & crackers! Makes great tarter sauce. 8 oz. Jar


Click to Order
$5.25 per jar
     
Cherries & Nuts Granola
Grab a hand-full and eat up! Enjoy this sweet,
salty crunchy treat! Great for breakfast or
just a snack. Oatmeal, dried tart cherries,
salted peanuts, coconut, dates,
sesame seeds, coated with brown sugar,
vanilla & cinnamon. 1 lb bag


Click to Order
$7.00 per bag
     

A GREAT BAG OF SPICY NUTS!
We're running out of time and had no other
better name for this roasty-toasty spicy bag
of nuts! Crunch into a handful of tasty almonds, pistachios, pine nuts and pepitas and enjoy
the flavor festival that's going on in your mouth!
We've combined the unique flavor these nuts with maple syrup and the zing of cayenne! Wow! This is "a great bag of spicy nuts!" 1 lb bag


Click to Order
$9.00 per bag
     
     

 

 

DON'T FORGET THE SALSA!

a pepper-based salsa that reveals a fresh, sweet taste that gives way to some tantalizing heat! Our recipe includes the freshest and the best combination of sweet peppers, hot peppers and the in-between peppers
. 16 oz jar
It's Loud & Bossy!


Click to Order Big Sister Salsa
$5.75 per jar

How about a trio?
$16.50 for three jars

Or a Six-Pack?
$33.00 for six jars


Maybe a Half-Rack?

$63.25 for 12 jars

 

Grab-N-Go Gift Bags
Here are some great Indiana food gift ideas that won't break the bank!
Chocolate Time! $30

Nothing says "I love you like" chocolate and caffeine! Here's a little fun goodie bag that is packed with wonderful treats.
Brunoscotti- Better Than Biscotti, Sunrise Coffee, Best Boy Co. Hot Fudge Sauce & I Love You Jam.
All wrapped up in a glassine bag with a handmade bow! Cute!


Click to Order
$30.00
Breakfast Time! $24

Wake up! It's pancakes! Greenfield Mills Pancake Mix, Indiana Maple Syrup & Two Cookin' Sisters Jam

Tea Time! $25

Take that break in the afternoon. You deserve it! Victorian House Scones, Two Cookin' Sisters Jam & Mundi Teas
.
Two Cookin' Sisters Fun Basket! $82
Small Fun Basket $50


It's a lot of fun foods & snacks! Great for families, office & friends! NJP Gourmet Popcorn, Tortilla Chips, Wolf's Chocolates Deluxe 24 Box, Tell City Pretzels, Big Sister Salsa, Juhoodle's Fudge, DipStick Pretzels, Grannies Garden Hot Carrots, Zesty Sweet Mustard, Chef T's Dip Mix.
Eat up!

Sizes
Supper Time! $23

It's a stick-to-the-ribs hot dish! George's Canned Beef, Prime Rib Under the Lid!, Coe's Homemade Noodles, Two Cookin' Sisters Old-Fashioned Apple Butter.
Cocktail Time! $23

Tea not your thing? Then, Bloody Mary's it is! Hoosier Momma Bloody Mary Mix, Two Cookin' Sisters Hot Carrots & A Great Bag of Spicy Nuts!
 

Gift Baskets, etc.
 
Sweetheart Special

Two beautiful locally handmade, over-sized soup mugs with a bag of Pasta Fagioli from NK Hurst Beans from Indianapolis, Indiana.
The mugs are great for soup, cereal, coffee, tea & hot chocolate! $44.95

Click to Order
$44.95
     

Happy Hour Basket

Close the shop, wrap it up, and pour me a stiff one! It’s Happy Hour!
A great basket to give to someone that loves that special hour of the day. Kick back, drop some ice in a glass & have a snack! Hoosier Momma’s Bloody Mary Maker, Hot& Sour Dilly Beans, Local Folks Foods Smoke Red Hot Sauce, Sechler’s Hot Chunky Dill Mix, A Great Bag of Spicy Nuts & two Indiana tall drink glasses.


Click to Order
$72.00
     
Two Cookin’ Sisters BIG Basket

All things good from the kitchen of Two Cookin’ Sisters! This gift box features an assortment of our specialty foods. All things good from the kitchen of Two Cookin’ Sisters! This gift basket features an assortment of our specialty foods. Big Sister Salsa, Grannie’s Garden Sweet Dill Pickles, Cherries & Nuts Granola, A Great Bag of Spicy Nuts, Moots Creek Craizinutapple Butter & 2 seasonal jams! BEST SELLER!

Click to Order
$55.00
     

Indiana Backyard BBQ Bucket

We've updated our popular BBQ Bucket! New Made in Indiana goodies! Share & enjoy Bonz BBQ Sauce, Mama Selita's Jalapeno Ketchup, Senora Rita's Cucumber- Jalapeno Relish, Grannie's Garden Sweet Dill Pickles, Zesty Sweet Mustard & Hot Carrots! The perfect gift for summer time festivities! The guys in the wedding party! Dad's Day! Hostess gift for family reunions! All these goodies are tucked into a reusable galvanized bucket that you can use in the garden or fill it up with cold beer! !


Click to Order
$45.00
     
Indiana Breakfast Basket

We've updated our Indiana Breakfast Basket to include some of our newest Indiana specialty food finds. Enjoy a bag of Old Canal Coffee Roasters coffee beans, Brunoscotti's Biscotti, Greenfield Mills Pancake Mix, Snider's Maple Syrup, Big Sister Salsa, Cherries & Nuts Granola & 2 seasonal jams from Two Cookin' Sisters. $65.

Small version Includes Old Canal Coffee, Greenfield Mills Pancake Mix, Maple Syrup & TCS seasonal Jam $38

Click to Order
$65.00

Click to Order
$38.00
     
Two Cookin' Sisters Jam 6-Pack

Here's your chance to get a great sampling of our jams & preserves.A variety of six seasonal or new jams to try.


Click to Order
$30.00
     
Small Two Cookin' Sisters Basket

Just a small taste of what we have to offer! Big Sister Salsa, Sweet Dill Pickles, Craizinutapple Butter & a Seasonal Jam!


Click to Order
$30.00
   

Big Sister Salsa Basket

We’ve tucked three jars of BIG SISTER SALSA into a cute little reusable basket!
You can use the basket to serve chips at your next party!

OR what about a

Sweet Dill Pickle Basket
Three jars of our popular Sweet Dill Pickles packed up ready to enjoy


Click to Order
$25.00

Click to Order
$25.00
 
Made in Indiana Specialty Products
 

NEW! Brunoscotti®-Better Than Biscotti!

12 oz. Bag- 6 Brunoscotti- $9.95

Handmade Italian Cookies! Classic Almond, our best seller, this classic is packed full of the best quality whole almonds. So fresh, you don’t have to dunk. Seasonal Flavors; Please call for Availability!

BIG B Pork BBQ Sauce

If you grew up near Evansville, Indiana, you know BIG B Pork BBQ! Spicy BBQ sauce with sliced pork served best on a toasted bun, or an English muffin with cheddar cheese! Quick & easy!
$8.95 2 Lb. Jar


Click to Order
$8.95

Gutwein Gourmet Microwave Popcorn
Indiana Popcorn from Francesville, Indiana!
The healthy snack! All great flavors!
$3.00 Box of 3 Bags
Butter Popcorn
Hot & Spicy Popcorn
Kettle Corn
Light Butter Popcorn
Flavors
Local Folks Food Ketchup

Reminds me of the homemade ketchup Mom used to make with tomatoes fresh from the garden. Big Seller! From Sheridan, Indiana, made with natural, fresh local ingredients.
$5.95 16oz.



Click to Order
$5.95
Local Folks Food Stone Ground Mustard

Customers LOVE it! From Sheridan, Indiana, made with natural, fresh local ingredients. $4.95 8oz.


Click to Order
$4.95
Wolf's Fine Handmade Chocolates- Deluxe Assortment
Delicious chocolates from America's heartland- Attica, Indiana! Only the finest, fresh quality ingredients. Crunchy nuts, real butter, pure oil flavoring & extracts. No preservatives or additives. Just the best!
8 Piece Deluxe Assortment- $6.95
15 Piece Deluxe Assortment- $11.95
24 Piece Deluxe Assortment- $19.95
Choices
Real Indiana Sorghum

Gold Run Sorghum from Camden, Indiana! Real sorghum made from the sorghum plant, not a blend! Great for baking, ham-n-beans, cornbread, biscuits, oatmeal & grits!
$4.95 Pint



Hoosier Momma Bloody Mary Maker

It’s the hot new ticket out of Indiana! Locally grown tomatoes paired with spicy savina chilis, citrus, horseradish & a blend of secret spices!

Vegan, gluten free & all natural!
32oz. -$10.95 (8 servings)


Click to Order
$10.95
Mama Selita’s Jalapeno Ketchup

A spicy blend of jalapenos & ketchup. Made in Indiana by Red Gold. Very good!

Really like it on just about everything that needs ketchup!
8oz. -$4.95


Click to Order
$4.95
Local Folks Foods Mushroom & Garden Vegetable Pasta Sauce

24 oz. Jar - $8.95

Good food made for local folks by local folks! Can’t get any better than that! A wonderful, fresh pasta sauce made with Indiana tomatoes, slow simmered for hours and authentically seasoned for your enjoyment! Sheridan, Indiana


Click to Order
$8.95
George's Country Beef- Boneless Beef Chunks

It's prime rib under the lid! Perfect for a batch of beef-n-noodles or homemade beef vegetable soup! On George's Indiana farm, cattle are fed the old-fashioned way on green pastures and natural grains. No hormones, steroids or animal by-products.
$12.95 for 27 oz. can

Click to Order $12.95
Coe’s Homemade Noodles

Judy Coe from Lynn, Indiana has been making noodles for over 25 years, and her dedication to a good noodle shows! One of our customers recommended Coe's Homemade Noodles- so, we had to have them! They are good! We've got lots of noodles- thick and thin-by the pound! $4.95 lb. bag

Click to Order $4.95
Momma's Old-Fashioned Applesauce

16 oz. pint jar of Momma's labor of love!
Momma used her kitchen to create healthy foods for her three kids. This applesauce recipe is one of her best! It kept the kids, neighbors and family coming back for a healthy sweet treat! Rossville, Indiana.- $5.95


Click to Order $5.95
N.K. Hurst Bean Soup Trio:
Ham Beans, 15 Bean Soup, Pasta Fagioli Soups

The original HamBeen Brand from N.K Hurst Company from Indianapolis, Indiana! Pinto beans with ham flavor. This is the perfect bag of beans for a pot of old-fashioned ham-n-beans!
15 Bean Soup- A colorful variety of wonderful beans! Exactly 15 different beans! Just add pork or sausage and tomatoes and you've got soup!
Pasta Fagioli- A lowfat hearty soup of pasta and beans! One of the most popular soups in the store! Add chicken or sausage and veggies. Makes a great pot of soup with plenty to share! Indianapolis, Indiana.- $12.50


Click to Order $12.50
Gutwein Gourmet
Popcorn Ears

3 Ears- Pop it in the microwave!
Some of Indiana's finest popcorn! A great novelty snack! Pop the popcorn right off the cob! Place one ear in one of the special microwave bags, set your microwave oven for 2-3 minutes, and you've got popcorn right off the cob! Great gift item, fun for the kids! Enjoy one of nature's greatest 'healthy snack!" Francesville, Indiana.- $5.95


Click to Order $5.95
Gutwein Gourmet Popcorn

2lbs. of Indiana popcorn in re-sealable bag
Some of Indiana's finest popcorn! Pop it on the stove or in the microwave! Gutwein Popcorn is produced on fertile soil resulting in the highest quality popcorn kernels and the best tasting popcorn. Enjoy one of nature's greatest 'healthy snack!" Francesville, Indiana. - $4.95

Click to Order $4.95
Sechler's Sweet Zesty Bread & Butter Pickles
24 oz. jar Fresh Pack- Old-fashioned Pickles!
Delicious fresh cucumbers, banana peppers and onions. After 75 years Sechler's is still family owned, operated and is still located near St. Joe, Indiana. Traditions like family ownership, original recipes, and fresh, quality ingredients haven't changed. "We could make them faster, but that wouldn't make them better." St. Joe, Indiana. - $6.25

Click to Order $6.25
Victorian House Scones Original Recipe
Just add butter & buttermilk!


This is the scone that began it all. It is the most versatile of all the mixes. You can add your own fruits; blueberries, raspberries, or chocolate chips. Or, add fresh dill and cheddar cheese. Split, and served with fresh strawberries and ice cream, and you have the best strawberry shortcake around! Lafayette, Indiana.Serves 16

Click to Order $9.95
Sublette's Ribs Dan's Original BBQ Sauce
16oz. Bottle Hot 0r Mild


The recipe is so secret; Dan's Mom doesn't even know the recipe! A local favorite hang out is Sublette's Ribs Restaurant in Monticello, Indiana! Dan created this wonderful sauce to be brushed on or poured on 15 minutes before meat is completely cooked. Great on beef, pork or chicken! Monticello, Indiana.


Click to Order $6.95

Lani's Hawaiian Gold Teriyaki Sauce
12 oz. Bottle


A favorite recipe of friends and family became a great side business. A delicious combination of soy, ginger, garlic and spices. Great on chicken, fish, beef & pork! Monticello, Indiana
.


Click to Order $7.95

 

Payment Options:

*Your options for payments are secure through Pay Pal using your credit card or through money order/personal check via mail order. Note: Sorry, currently all orders are shipped via United Parcel Service within the Contiguous U.S. ONLY.

*To pay via Mail Order click
HERE

If you have any payment questions, please contact us at: bossy@bigsistersalsa.com

     
talk to us!
  Good Food should be shared & enjoyed by all  
     

Downtown Brookston
210 South Prairie Street
  Good Food should be shared & enjoyed by all